SEC Football Schedule has in past and still is benefitting Alabama and Georgia

Alabama last year had to play Tennessee and Kentucky from the East and their conference record was 1-15 while LSU had to play Florida and Georgia and their record was 14-2. Doesn’t seem fair does it? In the old days Tennessee would have been a top 10 team almost every year and playing them as a permanent opponent was pretty tough for Alabama in the 1990’s and even pretty tough on them in the 2000’s too until recently. Will things change back again? I don’t know. Arkansas is a pretty easy team to play right now too. Last year we went 4-8, but in 2010 we went to a BCS bowl and in 2011 we finished 11-2 and ranked #5. In fact, Tennessee played Arkansas when they were ranked #3 and Georgia when they were ranked #2 and Alabama when they were ranked #1. That had not happened since 1971 when Iowa St (coached by Johnny Majors) played Nebraska, Oklahoma and Colorado when they were ranked in the top 3 positions.

Mike Strange: A stronger Tennessee levels SEC playing field

In case you’ve missed it while on the royal baby watch, there has been considerable hand-wringing over inequities in the SEC football schedule.

“I’d have to say,’’ LSU coach Les Miles said last week at SEC Media Days, “there’s a repeated scheduling advantage and disadvantage for certain teams in this conference based on tradition and traditional matchups.’’

Steve Spurrier couldn’t resist chiming in, noting the paths Alabama and Georgia took to the 2012 SEC championship game:

“Alabama didn’t play the top three teams in the East and Georgia did not play the three top teams in the West. Scheduling does make a difference.’’

You know who could resolve this travesty of justice and level the playing field?

Tennessee could.

If the Vols could get back to being the power program they were at the end of the 20th Century when the SEC designated its permanent (traditional) rivals, a lot of the “in” would disperse from the inequity.

Consider the route to the 2013 Western Division title: Alabama’s two East Division opponents were a combined 1-15 in SEC games last year. Permanent opponent Tennessee was 1-7, rotating opponent Kentucky 0-8.

LSU’s two East opponents were 14-2. Permanent opponent Florida and rotating opponent Georgia were both 7-1.

In 1992 when the SEC expanded to 12 teams and split into divisions, the 5-2-1 format called for two permanent non-divisional opponents and one rotating. Alabama and Arkansas were UT’s permanent opponents.

In 2003, the format changed to 5-1-2. Tennessee kept Alabama, shed Arkansas and got two rotating West teams.

The theory was to match strong against strong, weak against weak.

The strong: UT-Alabama, LSU-Florida, Georgia-Auburn. The weak were Ole Miss-Vandy and Kentucky-Mississippi State. Arkansas-South Carolina was more of a middle-ground, newcomer pairing.

With the additions of Missouri and Texas A&M in 2012, the 6-1-1 format is one permanent on the other side, one rotating.

Beginning in 2014, neighbors Arkansas and Missouri become permanent rivals. That leaves South Carolina and Texas A&M as distant but permanent rivals.

The problem with the formula is Tennessee hasn’t kept up its end of the bargain as a power program.

In the 21 years of divisional play, UT and ’Bama are 10-10-1 head-to-head. Perfect pairing.

But over the past five seasons, Alabama is 35-5 in SEC play, stronger than ever. Tennessee is 12-28, strong no more. The Tide has won six straight with an average victory margin of 23.3 points.

Meanwhile, LSU has to duke it out with Florida. The Tigers are 28-12 (SEC)

over the past five years, Florida 27-11. Fair fight.

“Scheduling,” said Miles, “should not in any way decide championships repeatedly or throughout.’’

But of course it does, and to some extent always has.

Up until 1992, the Vols played Georgia or Florida sporadically. Florida rarely played Alabama, etc.

The disparity works both ways. Tennessee is currently at a disadvantage by facing Nick Saban’s juggernaut every year. Georgia hasn’t played Alabama since 2008.

Trading Alabama for, say, Ole Miss, Auburn or Arkansas in a given year probably would have gotten the Vols to bowl games the past two seasons. To Tennessee’s credit, there hasn’t been any official whining.

That originates mostly at LSU. Saban, who had to play Florida every year when he was LSU’s coach from 2000-2004, points out that the only equal path to a championship comes when everybody plays everybody.

That works in a 10-team Big 12 Conference that plays nine league games. It’ll never happen in a 14-team SEC stuck on eight games.

But at least the Vols could help level the playing field by pulling their weight again.

Mike Strange may be reached at Follow him on Twitter at Strangemike44.

Related posts:

Tennessee Football’s 10 Most Heartbreaking Losses, 1989-2007 (The Hogs made the list twice!!) Part 2

Photo by Saul Young Former UT quarterback Peyton Manning, center, is congratulated by head coach Phil Fulmer as his jersey is retired Saturday before the South Carolina game in 2005. The hogs made the list twice: Tennessee Football’s 10 Most Heartbreaking Losses, 1989-2007 By Will Shelton (Senior Analyst) on August 12, 2008 2,722 reads 25 […]

Tennessee Football’s 10 Most Heartbreaking Losses, 1989-2007 (The Hogs made the list twice!!) Part 1

Photo by BYRON SMALL/KNOXVILLE NEWS SENTINEL Septermber 2, 1997 – University of tennessee football Coach Phillip Fulmer announced Monday, Nov, 3, 2008, his plans to step down. Here’s Fulmer talks with then UT quarterback Peyton Manning on the sidelines. The hogs made the list twice: Tennessee Football’s 10 Most Heartbreaking Losses, 1989-2007 By Will Shelton […]

Hogs benefit by trading Kentucky for Tennessee in 2012 football schedule?

Photo by Amy Smotherman Burgess Tennessee wide receiver Justin Hunter (11) reaches for a catch under pressure from North Carolina State defensive back Juston Burris (11) during the Chick-Fil-A Kick Off Game at the Georgia Dome in Atlanta on Friday, Aug. 31, 2012. Tennessee won the game 35-21. (AMY SMOTHERMAN BURGESS/NEWS SENTINEL STAFF) ____________ Tennessee […]

Tennessee Vols thrilled about not playing Hogs in football this year!!!

David Climer: Titles can’t erase SEC football’s weaknesses

SEC has proved how good we are, but it doesn’t mean every team in the SEC could win a national title in 2013. David Climer: Titles can’t erase SEC football’s weaknesses Alabama players celebrates after their 32-28 win in the Southeastern Conference championship NCAA college football game against Georgia, Saturday, Dec. 1, 2012, in Atlanta. (AP […]

SEC football recruiting Part 1

ESPN’s final recruiting rankings are not as good as others as I have seen. I do have a hard time with Missouri (38) having such a good ranking when other services had the tigers tanking their class this year compared to other SEC schools. However, Kentucky (36) is almost as bad when there is vast […]

SEC football recruiting roundup 2013

Nick Saban Streeter Lecka We finally found a Top 25 in which the SEC is more dominant than the USA Today Coaches’ Poll: the post-Signing Day recruiting class rankings. ________   I have to say the SEC is really doing well these days. Everyone expects Alabama is going to be on top on most years […]

SEC has 7 teams in top 12 in football recruiting, Ark is last in SEC!!!

It is really troubling to me that my Arkansas Razorbacks are 14th in the SEC in football recruiting this year and there are only a couple of days left till signing day. Alabama came in and got our best running back from North Little Rock high and I was told yesterday that Hunter Henry of […]

SEC Football Recruiting

I am not so mad anymore about Arkansas being ranked number 64 in recruiting this year while Auburn is #20 and Tennessee is #30 and even Kentucky is doing better than us. That is because they racked up lots of players when they had coaches during the year while we had John L. Smith. What […]

Ghosts of Ole Miss broadcast Part 2 Both Arkansas and Ole Miss had racial problems in 1960′s while also have their best years in football then

Ole Miss Applauds 1962 Undefeated Rebels I am doing a series on the “Ghosts of Ole Miss broadcast.” I enjoyed watching the Ghosts of Ole Miss broadcast on ESPN on 1-27-13 with my mother. She went to Ole Miss in the early 1960′s. Also living in Little Rock my wife has relatives that were also […]

Hogs mentioned in national football recruiting article (Lane Kiffin is an idiot by the way)

How good is Arkansas doing in football recruiting in 2013?

It is truly sad that Arkansas is ranked #62 in recruiting in the 2013 football class so far. The thing that troubles me the most is that there are 4 schools in the SEC that have brought in new coaches and Arkansas is one of them. However, what upsets me most is that the other […]

Most significant football games of all time

The fifty most significant games of all-time? That is what the article said. I don’t have time to go through all of them but I have listed a few from that list below. Here are some games listed below: October 7, 1916 Yes, there is a most lopsided victory in college football and it […]

Callers on radio talk shows in Tennessee want Petrino, but does Ark St?

I just got back from Memphis and it seemed that every other Vol fan that called in wanted Bobby Petrino as their new Tennessee football coach. However, there is a new report that Petrino has been seen on Ark St’s campus reported by Ark Times and there is a report that Petrino has called and […]

Is it time for Tennessee to look to Bobby Petrino?

I have posted before about the possibility that Petrino would go to Tennessee. Off the website of the Knoxville newspaper they have pictures of 10 possible replacements for Derek Dooley and here is the best choice my view: AP2011 Former Arkansas head coach Bobby Petrino. Despite his disgraceful exit from Arkansas, Petrino is going to […]

Mike Gundy will be named Arkansas Razorback Football Coach!!!!

I was listening to 103.7 FM the  buzz at 11:30 and a source close to the Athletic Director told David Bazzel that Mike Gundy of Oklahoma St will be named the Razorback coach. Below is an article from earlier today that said Gundy was considering an offer. It is still unclear if Chris Petersen was […]

Chris Petersen next Arkansas Razorback football coach?

I first read this on Jason Tolbert’s blog, but I did not take it serious. However, on Dec 2, 2012, I heard Bill Vickery say on his “Sunday Buzz” show on 103 .7 FM that a friend of his who was an agent contends that Jeff Long is working out the final details with Chris […]

Tennessee going after Petrino?

I heard a rumor on Friday that Kentucky was going after Bobby Petrino and today I read in the Knoxville Paper that Petrino would be a good fit for Tennessee. Where will Bobby land? John Adams: If not Jon Gruden, how about Bobby Petrino or Tommy Tuberville? By John Adams Posted November 11, 2012 […]

SEC football coaches on the hot seat

It is no surprise that John L. Smith and Derek Dooley may be heading out the door at the end of this season. That was expected by most people that watch SEC football. However, could Gene Chizik of Auburn being out the door too? If that happens then I must admit that I did not […]

SEC Football Schedules for 2013 Part 1

I am very happy with the new football schedules that the SEC released for next year. It is a stand alone schedule that will not affect the final decision that make concerning the rotation in the 2014 schedule and beyond. 2013 Georgia Bulldogs Football Schedule Date   Opponent Time/TV Tickets Saturday 04/06/13 G-Day Spring Game […]

Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: