Arkansas a model for other states on Medicaid expansion, I hope not!!!!

Arkansas a model for other states on Medicaid expansion, I hope not!!!! This is a great article and I am sad that many of the Republicans in Arkansas are actually trusting the Obama administration to keep their word. Currently we have 3 scandals with this administration and that speaks volumes about their integrity.

Think Again: The Arkansas Plan for Medicaid Is Still a Bad Idea

 

Photo credit: Newscom

Newscom

In a desperate attempt to keep the Obamacare Medicaid expansion alive, supporters are trying to break the logjam by suggesting states pursue an “Arkansas model.” However, there are several reasons why it is still a bad idea:

  • Accepts the expansion and funding. Supporters of the Arkansas plan suggest it is an alternative to the Obamacare Medicaid expansion. This is hardly the case. The Arkansas plan would agree to the full expansion of up to 138 percent of the federal poverty level (FPL) and would draw down on the new federal dollars. The Medicaid expansion would add millions to a government program that is struggling to meet the needs of its current enrollees and would fuel the country’s entitlement crisis by accepting new federal funding promises that the country simply cannot afford.
  • Medicaid rules still apply. Supporters argue that the Arkansas plan is not Medicaid, but it is clear that states must still provide Medicaid level benefits and protections. In its Good Friday memo, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services clarified, “Under all these [premium support] arrangements, beneficiaries remain Medicaid beneficiaries and continue to be entitled to all benefits and cost-sharing protections.” Thus ruling out any real deals for the states.
  • Details matter. Supporters imply that passage of an Arkansas-like plan through a state legislature makes it a done deal. Again, far from it. The state must still receive, in writing, official approval from the federal government, including Arkansas. And any agreement “in principle” is still not an official agreement. While there are limited instances where a state could submit a premium support plan without a waiver, the Secretary of Health and Human Services must still review such agreements and could still require a state pursue a more cumbersome waiver process.
  • Private coverage in name only. Supporters argue that the Arkansas plan is based on conservative ideas of integrating private coverage. However, any idea that coverage offered through the Obamacare government exchanges is private coverage is wishful thinking. The private plans offering coverage in the exchange must meet new federally defined benefits and regulations. In essence, the private plans in the exchanges are simply administering the government options.
  • No clear way out. Supporters of an Arkansas-like plan suggest the states can always back out of the deal and expansion if terms turn sour. However, it remains unclear whether any so-called sunset or escape clauses are viable. As two legal experts warn, the Supreme Court’s decision could be interpreted as voluntary to enter into the expansion but once accepted the expansion population may be mandatory.

None of this, of course, resolves the obvious issues that states would be taking on more responsibility, more obligations, and more spending than they otherwise would have. The Arkansas plan is a distraction from the real problems facing Medicaid. Rather than adopting the Obamacare Medicaid expansion, states should instead focus on addressing the deficiencies and challenges of those people currently served by Medicaid.

Related posts:

Medicaid mistake in Arkansas

I know and love many of the Arkansas Republicans that voted for this poor solution in Arkansas but my friend Dan Greenberg got it right in this article below when he takes them to task. Medicaid Expansion in Arkansas: A Fig Leaf, Not a Solution Dan Greenberg April 30, 2013 at 5:05 pm As action […]

 

‘Why Indiana Shouldn’t Fall for Obamacare’s Medicaid Expansion’

Expanding government is not right. Take a look at this article: APRIL 25, 2013 6:35PM ‘Why Indiana Shouldn’t Fall for Obamacare’s Medicaid Expansion’ By  MICHAEL F. CANNON SHARE My latest oped, in the Indy Star: Meanwhile, many [Medicaid] enrollees can’t even find a doctor. One-third of primary care physicians won’t take new Medicaid patients. Only 20 percent of […]

 

Conservatives win the first round in the medicaid expansion debate

  I was glad to see that the true Tea Party Conservatives won the first round in the medicaid expansion debate. According to AFP in the last 5 years Arkansas’ current Medicaid program has run a deficit of a billion dollars. Why expand it willingly with Obama? The “Do Nothing” expansion plan increases spending by […]

 

Will President give up any control of Medicaid program to the states?

CATO Institute Michael Cannon on the OReilly Factor Published on Mar 19, 2013 The CATO Institute’s Michael Cannon spoke at the Arkansas Conservative Caucus on Tuesday March 19th. Several conservatives were present. Cannon talked about how to defeat Obamacare in Arkansas & how the states can stop Obamacare on a national level. Max Brantley of […]

 

Rick Crawford warns Republican state lawmakers about expanding medicaid program in Arkansas

Nic Horton Medicaid Expansion will “Cost Almost Double than Doing Nothing” part II _______ I am hopeful that the Arkansas Republican state lawmakers will not expand the broken medicaid program. Evidently Congressman Rick Crawford feels strongly about this too. Crawford: Even With Arkansas Plan, ObamaCare Is Unaffordable Crawford urges state legislators to reject ObamaCare, because […]

 

Heritage Foundation mentions Arkansas lawmakers and medicaid expansion

Mike Maharrey talks AR Medicaid Expansion on the PHP ______________ This article from the Heritage Foundation mentions that the lawmakers in Arkansas are getting ready to make a big mistake if they think they will get flexibility from Obamacare on Medicaid expansion. Administration Rules Out “Deals” on Medicaid Expansion Edmund Haislmaier April 3, 2013 at […]

 

Americans for Prosperity against expanding Medicaid in Arkansas

  A Red-Ink Train Wreck: The Real Fiscal Cost of Government-Run Healthcare Uploaded on Nov 9, 2009 This CF&P Foundation video explains why healthcare proposals in Washington will result in bloated government and higher deficits. This mini-documentary exposes the pervasive inaccuracy of congressional forecasts and succinctly lists 12 reasons why Obamacare will be a budget […]

 

Great article by Michael Cannon on Arkansas Medicaid expansion plan

CATO Institute Michael Cannon on the OReilly Factor Published on Mar 19, 2013 The CATO Institute’s Michael Cannon spoke at the Arkansas Conservative Caucus on Tuesday March 19th. Several conservatives were present. Cannon talked about how to defeat Obamacare in Arkansas & how the states can stop Obamacare on a national level. __________________ CATO Institute […]

 

States response to Obamacare and Medicaid expansion

Great article from Heritage Foundation: Chart of the Week: The States That Have Expanded Medicaid T. Elliot Gaiser March 13, 2013 at 5:30 pm         «Expanding Medicaid will be costly for most states. The authors of The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act of 2010 (Obamacare) threatened to strip all federal funding […]

 

Heritage Foundation says Arkansas would be “net payer” while NY would be “net saver” with medicaid expansion (editiorial cartoon included)

New York is the real winner in medicaid expansion  while Arkansas would lose out in the long run. The Arkansas Times has reported that Republican lawmakers were warming up to the idea of expansion recently. The representatives and senators in Arkansas need to take a close look at both this article below and this editorial […]

 

 

Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: